I first read this one a few years ago for my book club and was bitterly disappointed with it.  Fast forward a few years and for some reason this has popped up all over the book internet world, so I thought I might give it another go.  I have to say that I enjoyed it more the second time around, having understood where and how it fitted into the Jane Eyre story and for anyone that is a fan of the Brontes it is definitely worth a read and at 150 pages – a quick read at that!